Music in church.
What God has created for an awesome expression of praise, worship, solace, joy, meditation, conviction, challenge, surrender, and discipleship is sadly a major source of division in the Body of Christ and has been for centuries.
Now, I carry no thought that my posts about music will stop the division and confusion, but I must share what’s been mulling in my mind.
To backup my earlier point, I share a portion from a post I found in Christianity Today written by Ed Stetzer and Elmer Towns (May 28, 2013). In the article, they share a portion from their book, Perimeters of Light, some snapshots of the history of music wars within the Church.
“Get rid of that flute at church. Trash that trumpet, too. What do you think we are, pagans?”
200s: Instrumental music was almost universally shunned because of its association with debauchery and immorality. Lyre playing, for example, was associated with prostitution.
“Hymns to God with rhythm and marching? How worldly can we get?”
300s: Ambrose of Milan (339-397), an influential bishop often called the father of hymnody in the Western church, was the first to introduce community hymn-singing in the church. These hymns were composed in metrical stanzas, quite unlike biblical poetry. They did not rhyme but they were sometimes sung while marching. Many of these hymns took songs written by heretics, using the same meter but rewriting the words.
“The congregation sings too much. Soon the cantor will be out of a job!”
500s: Congregations often sang psalms in a way that “everyone responds.” This probably involved the traditional Jewish practice of cantor and congregation singing alternate verses.
“Musical solos by ordinary people? I come to worship God, not man!”
600s: The monasteries, referencing “Seven times a day I praise you” (Ps. 119:164), developed a seven-times-daily order of prayer. The services varied in content, but included a certain amount of singing, mainly by a solo singer, with the congregation repeating a refrain at intervals. The services were linked together by their common basis in the biblical psalms in such a way that the whole cycle of 150 psalms was sung every week.
“Boring, you say? Someday the whole world will be listening to monks sing these chants.”
800s: Almost all singing was done in chant, based on scales that used only the white keys on today’s piano. The monastery was the setting above all others where Christian music was sustained and developed through the Dark Ages.
“How arrogant for musicians to think their new songs are better than what we’ve sung for generations.”
900s: Music began to be widely notated for the first time, enabling choirs to sing from music. Thus new types of music could be created which would have been quite out of the reach of traditions where music was passed on by ear.
“Hymns that use rhyme and accent? Surely worship should sound different than a schoolyard ditty!”
1100s: The perfection of new forms of Latin verse using rhyme and accent led to new mystical meditations on the joys of heaven, the vanity of life, and the suffering of Christ.
“This complicated, chaotic confusion is ruining the church!”
1200s: Starting in France, musicians began to discover the idea of harmony. The startling effect of the choir suddenly changing from the lone and sinuous melody of the chant to two-, three-, or even four-part music did not please everyone. One critic commented how harmony sullied worship by introducing “lewdness” into church.
“Don’t try to sing that hymn at home; leave it to the professionals at church.”
1300s: Worship in the great Gothic-era cathedrals and abbeys used choirs of paid professionals, “a church within a church,” sealed off by screens from the greater building. Ordinary people generally had no place in the spiritual life of these great buildings, except perhaps in the giving of their finances.
“It’s too loud, and the music drowns out the words.”
1400s: Music became increasingly complex (Gothic sounds for Gothic buildings), prompting criticisms that only the choir was allowed to sing. As reformer John Wycliffe had complained, “No one can hear the words, and all the others are dumb and watch them like fools.”
“They want us to sing in today’s language. Shouldn’t God-talk be more special than that?”
1500s: The new prayerbook, pushed by King Henry VIII of England decreed that all services would be in English, with only one syllable to each note.
“Now they’re putting spiritual words to theater songs that everyone knows.”
1500s: Martin Luther set about reforming public worship by freeing the mass from what he believed to be rigid forms. One way he did this was by putting stress on congregational singing. He used hymns and music already familiar to the majority of people in Germany.
“Okay, men on verse 2, ladies on verse 3, and the organ on verse 4.”
1600s: The organ played an important part in Lutheranism, Anglicanism, and Roman Catholicism, while in the Reformed churches there was much opposition to it. Initially the organ was not used to accompany congregational singing, but had its own voice. As a result, the organist would often play a verse on the congregation’s behalf.
“Our children will grow up confused, not respecting the Bible as an inspired book.”
1700s: Isaac Watts gave a great boost to the controversial idea of a congregation singing “man-made” hymns, which he created by freely paraphrasing Scripture. Charles Wesley paraphrased the Prayer Book, and versified Christian doctrine and experience. Wesley’s songs were said to have had at least a great as influence as his sermons.
“Their leader is just asking for trouble when he says, ‘Why should the devil have all the best music?'”
1800s: William Booth, founder of The Salvation Army, used rousing melodies with a martial flavor to set the tone for his Army. He is credited with popularizing the “why should the devil” question referenced above.
“These Christian radio quartets are on a slippery slope. Don’t they realize that the airwaves are the domain of Satan, ‘prince of the power of the air’?” (Eph. 2:2).
1900s: When radio was in its infancy, a handful of Christian pioneers such as Donald Grey Barnhouse and Charles E. Fuller began featuring gospel music and evangelistic teaching over the airwaves. Many Christians initially showed skepticism.
“Christian Rock is an oxymoron. The music of the world must not invade the church.”
1970s: Larry Norman sang, “I want the people to know, That He saved my soul, But I still like to listen to the radio…They say that rock and roll is wrong…I know what’s right, I know what’s wrong and I don’t confuse it: Why should the devil have all the good music…’Cause Jesus is the Rock and He rolled my blues away.” He founded what became known as Contemporary Christian Music… and it is still controversial today.
Interesting enough, I have heard some of those same statements made about today’s songs that were made about the “old hymns.”
And I guess I should have separated from my dear mom who learned to play the piano by faithfully listening to Rudy Atwood play the piano for the Old-Fashioned Revival Hour led by Charles E. Fuller. He was using Satan’s airwaves every week (see 1900’s above). And many who heard my mom play the piano have wished for her to be back on earth playing again because she played the “old songs.” It’s a vicious cycle.
Satan does all he can to distract and divide us over issues that are not clearly outlined in Scripture. A principle that I have tried to live by for many years simply says, “Where man makes issue, and God makes none, it’s the sign of a man-made doctrine, and you’d better leave it alone.” (Quote author unknown)
Just a thought: We will divide over music styles that are not clearly defined in the Word of God, but we’ll sin in ways that are clearly an offense to our holy God to defend our music position: pride, gossip, anger, cliques, misuse of Scripture, idolatry, and many more.
Please don’t throw stones at me yet. Just sharing my heart. More to come.
2 thoughts on “Get Rid of That Flute! Trash That Trumpet!”
Amen! Well said! I think the enemy loves our petty distractions from the object of our adoration. As a touring musician, I find myself fighting pettiness internally at church when the mix is bad, or the stylistic choices too uniform. Yet, the Holy Spirit, usually though the mouth of my wife rebukes me, and reminds me that it’s all for his pleasure, not mine.
As a child of the 1970-80’s, I was right there in controversy central as my Baptist church had style wars. Organ vs. piano? Contemporary vs. Christian rock? It was pretty tough to be a drummer in a church tradition where I could feel the animosity of the elders who’s unspoken message was “G-d doesn’t like drums”. It didn’t take long to realize that we are the limited ones, not the Lord. Count me in the camp that worship music is the ultimate challenge for any musician, from any culture, at any time in history. How can we create enough variety to describe His infinity? How can we consider ourselves masterful instrumentalists, writers, or singers in the context of eternity? Yet, He takes pleasure at our musical color crayon pictures, and puts them on His fridge!?! A genuine heart makes beautiful music that no style or form can contain.
Thank you for taking time to respond! There are so many distractions in this life that seek to pull us away from living in awe of God!